Case studies/ Employment law in action

Employment law in action

Case studies©lumeworkplace

A genuine redundancy, defended and upheld

A mid-sized research organisation had made a considered, operationally-driven redundancy decision as part of a broader restructure. Leadership was confident in their reasoning. What they hadn’t planned for was a former employee lodging a General Protections claim in the Fair Work Commission, or how exposed a genuine decision can feel once it’s formally challenged.

Before coming to Lume, the organisation had no in-house legal expertise and no experience defending a claim like this. They needed more than a lawyer who could recite the law. They needed a team who understood how the restructure had actually unfolded on the ground, and could translate that into a response the Commission would take seriously.

We reviewed the circumstances of the redundancy alongside the people who made the decision, assessed the evidence available and built a response strategy grounded in the organisation’s real decision-making. Because our team works across law, IR and organisational strategy, we could see the full picture the way a purely legal adviser wouldn’t have, and build a defence that held together end to end.

“We knew our reasoning was sound, but we had no idea how to actually prove that to the Commission. Lume didn’t just handle the claim, they helped us understand our own process better than we did.”

General Manager

If you’re facing a claim over a decision you believe was fair, talk to us before you respond. Get in touch to find out where you stand.

Turning a legal claim into stronger foundations.

A well-established employer had followed what they believed was a fair and proper termination process. When the former employee lodged an unfair dismissal application, leadership wasn’t worried about the outcome so much as the unknown. Their documentation had never been tested, and they had no way of knowing whether it would hold up to scrutiny.

Most advisers would have simply run the claim and closed the file. Lume went further. Alongside preparing the Fair Work Commission response, we reviewed the organisation’s underlying employment documentation and processes, the parts most firms never look at unless something has already gone wrong, and showed leadership exactly where the next decision could carry less risk than the last.

We guided leaders through a process most had never navigated before, translating legal requirements into plain, practical decisions at every step, so they left the matter more confident, not just relieved it was over.

“The claim was resolved, but honestly the bigger win was what we learned about our own paperwork. We wouldn’t have known where the gaps were without Lume pointing them out.”

HR Director

Not sure if your documentation would hold up if it were tested? Submit an enquiry and we’ll help you find out before you need to.